ok. Sorry it took me so long to get this information. Battling a few illnesses with the young ones and been a little crazy. I was not sure where I left off on Saturday, so I did the following:
Cleared the port forward in the router.
Rebooted the router
Added the port forward back to the router.
Rebooted the router. Pic below.

Ensured the DHCP reservation was correct. .50 is outside my DHCP range of 100-200 (pic below)
On the server, I Turned off remote access.
Rebooted the server.
Turned on remote access and manually specified port 32400.
Rebooted the server again.
Hit retry on the remote access screen and still have the same error:
Please let me know if there is something else I can do to help. Thanks!

