For clarity, in my case, I only needed one movie as well.
it may have just been browser cache or something for me.
@BigWheel Just wanted to check in on this. Is this issue going to be seen by Plex as an actual bug or a feature at this point?
Labels were not originally part of collections I’m not sure it is supposed to be there in the first place as I cannot find any release notes about adding them to collections…
But since it is there and it is at least IMO inconsistent with what one would expect as you noted, so I made a issue report about that. I can’t say at this point what will be done about it when issues are triaged as it is not my call. I think it will not be a quick fix because afaik there would need to be a fundamental change in how hubs/rows are created so would need a probably not simple refactor.
@BigWheel Cheers for the info, at least I know it is not just being brushed off, thanks for the update. Would love as this fixed as it would help those of us looking to pin things to only specific people’s homescreens.
Probably here.
- Added support for editing Content Rating and Labels for collections
1 Like
thanks
Holy cow this finally works
@benfishbus It does not work as it is, there is a bug that is preventing the exclude permission on users from being applied to things that are pinned. Once this is fixed then it will.
@BigWheel This issue also rears its head when you view a movie that is in a collection to which a user does not have access. Follow me on this:
Setup:
Collection 1 has the label excluded
Movie 1 is a part of Collection 1
Movie 1 does not have the excluded label
User 1 has the label excluded added to their exclude option in restrictions section of the Manage Library Access screen.
Methodology:
User 1 cannot see Collection 1 in the collection list as expected
User 1 can view the entry for Movie 1 in the movie library as expected
User 1 clicks on Movie 1 and then can see Collection 1 listed at the bottom of the page even though they should not have access to it.
User 1 can click the header Collection 1 and view the rest of the movies that are in this collection, even though that should not have access.
What should happen:
When User 1 browses to Movie 1 they should be able to see it in the movie library and open the movie and read the metadata and watch it. They should not see Collection 1 at the bottom of the page. Nor should they be able to browse said collection if they somehow got to the collection page.
Again User 1 should have access to all movies, but should not have access to Collection 1. It looks like this might be a systemic issue when it comes to how privacy/security is handled when it comes to the exclude tags and not just the pinned items.
1 Like
This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.
Being reopened, does this mean any new news about this issue?
I’m still hoping it gets fixed.
1 Like
Great question
Just confirming this is still an issue and is easily reproducable.
To reproduce (requires seperate user test account):
1: Create a collection
2: Add label testing123
3: Set visibility to Users Home and Library Recommended
4: Set testing123 as a label restriction for the test user for the library you created the Collection in
5: Login to the test users account
4: On the Home page and Library Recommended, the Collection that shoud be restricted is fully visible
Same issue here. The collection DOES have a label and is excluded on the Library tabs. However, it is still visible on the user home screen.
