THIS is what I am talking about. This is what happened. It makes perfect sense, its happened to others before. I’ve heard that a Plex Admin on their end can possibly fix this for me. If not, me doing something from within Plex that should have warned me of this happening happened. Just because I wanted to manage both servers from a single interface (like a Vsphere situation) I screwed myself and all it did was give me 2 users, an admin name for each Server and it deleted all other 14 users I already had setup. Ugh I just can’t believe this wouldn’t be TOLD to me before I tried merging.