5.1 AC3 problem

Hi,

 

I want to play a video with an audio stream encoded in AAC/5.1, and rasplex reports the audio track correctly in the audio menu while playing the movie, but on my a/v receiver the stream appears as stereo. If I play the same video on my Plex Mac player, connected to the same receiver via optical audio, the receiver recognizes the stream as AC3 / Dolby Digital, and the output is correct (i.e. it looks like Plex server transcodes AAC/5.1 correctly to AC3/5.1).

 

The settings in rasplex and Mac Plex are the same (AC3 and DTS capable set to true, speaker config 5.1).

 

Rasplex v 0.2.2, clean install.

I also experience this problem on a few files...

it is the same situation to me as well....not only to some files but for all of them.

When this happens i just reboot and then it works fine

This happens too me as well! Earlier versions didn't had this issue.

I'll try a reboot tonight and report back..

Reboot is not going to solve the problem. It is a bug in the recent builds.

Reboot is not going to solve the problem. It is a bug in the recent builds.

Does anyone know when this will be fixed?

Regards

Have you tried 0.3.1?  Did you make sure that you checked the box in RasPlex preferences saying your receiver can decode AC3?

Can someone experiencing this please file a proper bug report?

We can't fix something that we can't reproduce : )

https://github.com/RasPlex/RasPlex/wiki/How-to-report-a-bug

Have you tried 0.3.1?  Did you make sure that you checked the box in RasPlex preferences saying your receiver can decode AC3?

Have flashed 0.3.1, even though boxes were checked for both AC3 and DTS, speakers set to 5.1, AC3 (Dolby Digital) plays fine, AAC5.1 plays as stereo!

Regards

[Edit]

Have played the same files on Plex for Samsung (which uses Plex HT) and Plex HT on my Macbook (connected via HDMI) and the AAC5.1 files play fine, still stereo on Rasplex.

I have a similar experience. No 5.1 only stereo.


(DVDs ripped using Handbrake on high setting which should include an AC3 track for pass through)


When I play movie files on rasplex 3.1 and press “I” button on the my keyboard, under settings (I have ticked receiver can decode dts and dolby decoder.)


Rasplex displays D (audio: AC3 ( ac-3 / 0x332D6361) 48000 Hz, 5.1 (side), s16, 448 kb/s) P (aq 99%, Kb/s 6136).


Rasp pi is connected to a Denon x3000 bought a month ago and up dated to latest firmware last week, but the audio file is only stereo according to the amp and amp information screen lists it as a PCM signal in stereo only.


Source of the files is a synology 412+ nas box


Kags

I would suggest waiting for 0.4, the experimental release 9.9.18 seems pretty stable, shouldn't be too long before a release (unless someone can find a showstopper).

Hello,

I have Installed the new version rc1 and I have the same problem, i can read all my films but in stereo in place of 5.1

Well just to make sure you guys activated AC3 / DTS passthrough and changed HDMI channels count from 2.0 to 5.1 right ?

Well just to make sure you guys activated AC3 / DTS passthrough and changed HDMI channels count from 2.0 to 5.1 right ?


See my original post - https://forums.plex.tv/topic/77016-51-ac3-problem/?p=548989

I am now on 0.4.0rc1 and can confirm that even though AC3 and DTS passthrough are activated and channel count is set to 5.1, that AC3 (Dolby Digital) plays fine, but AAC5.1 still plays as stereo! Playing the same AAC5.1 files via Plex DNLA (that is, not through Rasplex) the files play as 5.1!

This really needs fixing as AAC5.1 nows seems to be a popular encoding for DVB-T and DVB-T2 recorded HDTV programs.

Regards.

I am experiencing a similar experience with rc3

Files that are showing as Dolby Digital 5.1 are playing as stereo, 

I did find that plex output was set to 2 channel, so I changed that and rebooted. still no luck

I then changed checkboxes to DTS and AC3 capable amp and reboot, still no luck

All the settings on the server look ok.

I did notice that my AMP detects that the Rasplex is stereo as soon as you turn it on. Other devices such as the playstation come up as 5.1, so I'm thinking it might not be playback, but something in the OS is keeping it to 2 channel. I even switched the cables around to rule out AMP configuration.

I would expect this is a high priority to fix.

I am experiencing a similar experience with rc3

Files that are showing as Dolby Digital 5.1 are playing as stereo, 

I did find that plex output was set to 2 channel, so I changed that and rebooted. still no luck

I then changed checkboxes to DTS and AC3 capable amp and reboot, still no luck

All the settings on the server look ok.

I did notice that my AMP detects that the Rasplex is stereo as soon as you turn it on. Other devices such as the playstation come up as 5.1, so I'm thinking it might not be playback, but something in the OS is keeping it to 2 channel. I even switched the cables around to rule out AMP configuration.

I would expect this is a high priority to fix.

Quite a few things changed from rc3 to rc4. Have you tried the latest version?

Quite a few things changed from rc3 to rc4. Have you tried the latest version?


Still not working, and won't until the Gotham merge, no guarantees that it will then. There is a conversation in one of the issues on Github, anybody that's interested can follow progress there.

Regards

I would expect this is a high priority to fix.


Not a high priority, see my other post. When encoding your DVD/BR's in future I suggest that you use AC3 rather than AAC5.1 for the time being.

Regards

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.