Choosing a preferred server at login EVERYTIME

Everytime I login to my plex server through my web browser, I am asked to choose my preferred server then my default libraries. I only have one server. EVERY TIME. A long time ago, we had two different servers (one on each of 2 machines). I’m not even sure how this is showing up. Help!

Windows 10 machine running plex server and Firefox browser.

Have you removed the old server from your Authorized Devices list???

The old servers never showed up under the authorized device list. That’s what’s so strange.

  1. use the hosted web app app.plex.tv
  2. tell your web browser to not discard cookies and other “website data” from plex.tv when you close it