Multi-episode skip? or is this more of a bug?

If we’re never going to have the option to properly deal with multi-episodes within plex i.e; give us an option to merge/hide episodes if they are part of the same file, then can we at least be able to ignore the episode after it has played?

I’ve seen claims that this was implemented, yet if you manually skip an episode so you don’t have to watch the end credits, you just get the same episode again.

I would prefer a feature that would allow us to manually merge/hide duplicate episode or for it to be automatically merged/hidden if the source is identical.

So if the episode file name is S02E01E02, then plex should be capable of ignoring “E02”

If the dev’s are reluctant to do this then, if we skip an episode and the next episode is the same episode, then it should also skip that episode.

Just trying to catch up on this suggestion.
To be clear… Plex Media Server supports multiple episodes reflected in a single file. See Multiple episodes in a single file in the support article on how to name your tv-show files.

Plex will display that file as individual items – one for each episode included in that file. If you watch one of those episodes, Plex will mark all related episodes as watched and progress to the next episode (beyond the last episode within your file). If you manually trigger the playback of an item of the same file, the full episode will play again.

If your client repeats the same video, please specify which client that is – this would be more of a bug from all I can tell.

There’s an existing feature suggestion asking for a means to show those multi-episode files as a single item inside Plex (e.g. labelled as Episodes 1-2 instead of individual items for Episode 1 and Episode 2).

Firestick 4K,
LG WebOS,
Android Mobile,
Plex media player (PC)

Are the ones I’ve tested this on and it doesn’t skip the multi-episode files, it also shows the multi-episode file in the “Up Next” section at the end of the episode.

This typically requires me to either back right out and then select the next episode or to play the same file again and skip. It’s always been this way and I usually do my best to avoid multi-episodes specifically because of the poor handling of it by Plex, but, it’s been getting on my nerves recently, hence my post.

So I just want to clarify this to avoid confusion. If I have a multi-episode file called S01E01-02.mkv, Plex will show the same file twice as episode 1 and episode 2 (which tbh is stupid), but then after you watch episode 1 Plex will then show episode 2 as “Up next” and if I was to skip, it would play episode 2, or if I was to click on “up next” it would play episode 2, despite it being one file.

It’s done this for as long as I can remember, it was an issue when I first started using Plex about 5-6 years ago and I thought I could avoid it but some content gives you no choice.

Edit: just to add, I think it might skip the episode if I let it just play through, but I typically just skip as I don’t want to sit through 2-5 minutes of end credits.

The original thread/feature request where it says it was implemented back in 2017 (but it has been a problem even before it.) It was apparently fixed in version 118.3.2111. If it was implemented as listed below it would solve the issue for 99.9% of issues

From the Mod OttoKerner:
A different approach was implemented in Plex Server now (as of version 1.18.3.2111):
Episodes in the same file are marked as ‘watched’ too.
Duplicate enqueuing of the same file is prevented.

As far as I can tell this DOES NOT WORK. Im not sure if it has ever worked, maybe its a regression bug.

The final comment essentially says that its implemented as part of 1.18 and no one currently wants it. Alot of the people in the thread dont understand what the original request is asking for.

This comment essentially sums up the issue.
JuiceWSAPlex Pass

Jul '17

A TV Show Library/
…TV Show Name/
…Season 01/
…TV Show Name - S01E01-E02.XXX

They will show in the library as two episodes. They will draw info from TVDB as two episodes. When Plex plays them it plays the file, you see episode 1 and episode 2, but Plex still thinks you need to watch episode 2. Of course when you play episode 2, you start the file over again, so you have to mark episode 2 as watched.

We cover this on a regular basis ad-nausium, but the BEST way to deal with episodes that have been joined is:

A TV Show Library/
…TV Show Name/
…Season 01/
…TV Show Name - S01E01.XXX <— edit this episode to contain both descriptions - or don’t worry about it.
…TV Show Name - S01E03.XXX <— Plex plays this episode as the next unwatched episode - no funny bidness.

‘Feature Requests’ going back YEARS are already in existence.
Every few weeks a new ‘Feature Request’ is created - nothing is done.
Irate Users show up and ■■■■■ about it - nothing is done.
Irate Users threaten to leave Plex - go ahead - Plex doesn’t care - nothing is done.

1 Like

Still waiting for them to improve playlists/collections, been wanting the ability to continue watching content from a playlist without having to go into that playlist, they’ve given us a workaround to tracking progress with smart playlists/collections, but that relies on the “unwatched” filter, I would still prefer a way to track my actual progress in a playlist and be capable of continuing that progress from on-deck/continue watching, requests for this particular feature have went as far back as 2015, with multiple users since then making the same feature request, including myself.

As an Irate user I understand they’re a business and they need to make money, I also understand that their go to is to add new features that they think will attract new users which I assume constantly improving the UI design is part of that, which is fine, I like the new UI.

But then what? they’ve got that person interested in their software and that person is now paying them monthly/yearly to use it, the moment they start noticing a minor issue, is the moment they’ll start to slowly become an irate user, they’ll begin to notice how people have consistently spoke about small details that plex could fix and nothing is done about it, but eventually those minor issues turn into such an inconvenience and the more you deal with those inconvenience the more you start to get irritated by it.

For example, I avoid playlists because they’re useless without the above mentioned improvements, I use collections but only to make it easier to navigate between similar content, thats all its good for, I even managed to avoid multi-episodes until I couldn’t avoid them anymore and I was forced to make this post back in february, at one point I was splitting episodes in half and adding the intro/outro to those files which is such a waste of time when it can be avoided, I have got to the point were I would avoid labeling multi-episodes, which looks horrible when you view a season and it looks like episodes are missing “01, 03, 05, 07 etc…” because for some reason every episode in Doc Mcstuffin or Peppa Pig has to be multi-episodes.

I don’t see a point in threatening to leave because it will be ignored, just like everything else. Although I will say that I know a few plex users who have already migrated to a competitor, I only know this because I’m in a plex group that talks about everything plex related from hardware to helping others and a few have mentioned that they made that move, not gonna lie, I’ve been tempted to at least give the competitor a try but for now my loyalities are with plex, which I undestand how idiotic that sounds given the circumstances.