Plex No Longer Auto-Matching Content

I know there are plenty of threads on here relating to this issue but I cant seem to find any exactly relevant to the issue I am having.

Auto-Matching used to work 100% of the time until about 6 months ago when it suddenly stopped. It sometimes works with TV shows, but never for movies. What is strange is that after I scan my library and it doesn’t load metadata, if i click “Refresh Metadata” on the individual titles it works first try every single time.

I have attached the snippet from the console where I can see the error occur.

For some reason, I have found that I have to search 2x usually to match my movies and TV shows. I have no idea why, but that second time works.