That means plex believes the second is a duplicate and not “part 1 & part 2”
You can use Mkvtoolnix to merge them into one single file. More info below.
EDIT: Link fixed. Thanks Otto!
Or name them so plex will know file 1 is part 1 and file 2 is part 2. More info below.
https://support.plex.tv/articles/200265006-naming-multi-file-tv-show-episodes/
1 Like