Which is the Best converting/copying software

_I mostly copy/remux mkv to mp4.
This is what I want to do.
Search my finished tv shows folder for mkv and avi.

Drop the MKV into a program that will copy/remux to mp4.
Then delete or move the mkv and leave the mp4 in the original tv show folder.

Drop avi into program and convert to mp4 - delete or move avi and leave mp4 in correct tv show folder
_
I have used
Vidcoder - very good but cannot do a copy/remux - Free
Shanencoder - cannot save in original folder or delete original - Free
MCE Buddy - remuxes are always 8 seconds shorter than original. - $30
VideoGo 6 - cannot move or delete mkv after it copied as mp4 - $30
Xmedia Recode - slow - free
Handbrake - cannot remux and GUI not user friendly- free
Video Converter - can’t remember -free
Video to Video - no remux ? - free
MediaCoder - no manual and buggy - $35.

I don’t mind paying a reasonable amount if it does what I want!!

1 Like

I use Xmedia Recode for remuxing, but as far as I am aware it’s functions are manual in nature, but can handle manually created queues staggering in volume.

Here’s how to fix MCEBuddy:

Find Bud’s ‘config’ folder - usually: C:\Program Files\MCEBuddy2x\config\

Reference: https://mcebuddy2x.codeplex.com/discussions/542787

To correct this you need to make 2 changes:
Open mcebuddy.conf, under the section ffmpegbackupremux remove the -ss 5 from all the lines
Open profile.conf, find your profile and remove -ss 3 and --start-at duration:3 from the appropriate lines

5+3=8

For most folks they’re using Bud for Recorded TV and have (hopefully) set their recording devices to start at least a minute before and end at least a minute after the exact scheduled time to account for start and end times that might not happen exactly on time and to give you a little ‘leader’ to work with. They’ll never notice 8 seconds missing and this gives Bud stable video in which to do it’s work - in case your recording device takes a few seconds to ‘settle down’ from a cold start. Unlikely, but possible.

Most of my work (and yours I assume) will be done in pre-edited material. If I intend to permanently add a Recorded TV item to my library I use VideoReDo TV Suite 5 for frame accurate editing of said material and there is no foolishness at the start or ends of items Bud has to work with. When I’m watching/deleting other, more disposable items that are handled automatically I’m unconcerned if a glitch shows up in the beginning (never seen one actually) 'cause I’m bumping through that leader to the start of the program anyway. We don’t need Bud’s safety net, so remove it.

These config files are also where you can make changes to the ffmpeg routines if you want to customize how Bud is doing it’s work and if one of the many presets doesn’t do exactly what you want done.

Handbrake is my all time favorite for encoding and my self-taught skills (is there any other way? I am unaware of the location of Handbrake University) allow me to tip-toe through those confusing settings with ease - and that didn’t happen overnight I can tell you.

BTW: MCEBuddy is technically free. I have been a long-time supporter because it does so much for me so that 30 dollar gift was cheap at twice the price. I can’t say I benefit by having access to the latest releases as a sibling uses Bud’s free version and from what we see they both are doing the same thing and doing it very well.

I did pay over a hundred bucks for VideoReDo TV Suite 5 - and that was money well spent too. There is simply no free solution that does frame accurate edits in mpeg2 streams to facilitate the manual removal of commercials (in the US those come every 7 minutes) and produce an edited WTV file to plop down in MCEBuddy’s monitor location in under 5 minutes. That I’m aware of anyway. MCEBuddy and Comskip are pretty good, but they ain’t that good.

I use Brorsoft, http://www.brorsoft.com/ and haven’t had any issues. It is pretty quick and the quality is excellent. I personally use the Blu-ray Video Converter Ultimate because of all the features but they also have scaled down versions. As far as the search options you mentioned, I have not personally tried it, I know it will find the files but I don’t know if it will put them back in the specific folder. They do have free trial offer to check it out though.

@JuiceWSA said:
I use Xmedia Recode for remuxing, but as far as I am aware it’s functions are manual in nature, but can handle manually created queues staggering in volume.

Here’s how to fix MCEBuddy:

Thanks Juice

That worked and it appears to be doing almost all I want.
Not sure how the schedule works!
“bud” looks for files every 300sec so is a schedule needed??

My guess is that you would use that feature if you only wanted Bud on the job (and devouring your CPU) at select times when you weren’t using it. I have my 720p Bud Install on 24/7 in the older box and it’s now devouring an edited version of American Experience - The Battle of Chosin while the 1080p Bud Install up here on the big box devours this week’s The Durrels and Indian Summers - it just finished eating this week’s Poldark (2015) and it looks great.

@JuiceWSA said:
My guess is that you would use that feature if you only wanted Bud on the job (and devouring your CPU) at select times when you weren’t using it. I have my 720p Bud Install on 24/7 in the older box and it’s now devouring an edited version of American Experience - The Battle of Chosin while the 1080p Bud Install up here on the big box devours this week’s The Durrels and Indian Summers - it just finished eating this week’s Poldark (2015) and it looks great.

I have Bud scheduled to do it’s thing from 2-6am.
BUT on checking task manager the Bud service is continuously using around 5% cpu resources out of those hours.

I have Bud scheduled to do it’s thing from 2-6am.
BUT on checking task manager the Bud service is continuously using around 5% cpu resources out of those hours

Any ideas?

Not really. If it’s on, it’s running as a service and is looking at the place it’s supposed to be looking at to monitor for new stuff. I suppose that takes some resources, but to be honest I never looked - or cared.

I just fired up Bud on this box and looked at TM - it shows it bouncing around in with the other services that are running. In my case no more than 1%, but mostly 0%. That doesn’t worry me. You shouldn’t worry either. Bud’s on the job. Sometimes he needs some coffee. Coffee costs money. There you go.

:slight_smile:

I use Smart Cutter to edit out commercials. To convert MKV to MP4 I use Wondershare Video Converter Ultimate. Tried many others, Wondershare is the best, very configurable, and converts just about any format to any format.

@cc_rider said:
I use Smart Cutter to edit out commercials. To convert MKV to MP4 I use Wondershare Video Converter Ultimate. Tried many others, Wondershare is the best, very configurable, and converts just about any format to any format.

Does wondershare search your media folders automatically and convert AVI and copy MKV then move the original to another folder ?

ffmpeg. I can’t remember what old software with gui I used that could remux mkv to mp4 in seconds but I am pretty sure anything after dvdfab 9 (converter tool) works perfectly for it. You just have to customize the settings for the format (mp4) that you want to keep from the mkv file. It takes the files out of the container and puts them into the mp4 container for you.

Then you can use a software called MetaX to edit your metadata for your mp4.

I asked this question a year ago so thought an update is due.

I now have MCEBuddy set to automatically search my tv folder for mkv and avi files.

avi it converts to MP4
mkv it remuxes to MP4

It works really well.

I d/l an mkv (or avi) but never actually see it as it turns up on my plex server as an mp4 ready for watching on almost everything.