Cannot get 2 servers on the one Plex or can I ?? HELP !!!

The second server shows up on the list but its in RED and says “Server is not accessible” (Unauthorised)

How can I make it available ???

Is this a shared server or your own?

Typically, Unauthorized means that the server is reachable but told your client that it isn’t authorized to access the server.

Yes you can, but keep in mind plex will only listen on port 32400, so you have to forward from a different port on the second server.

Server 1:
Internet --> 32400 WAN --> 32400 LAN

Server 2:
Internet --> 32401 WAN --> 32400 LAN

Just set the remote port on the second server to 32401 or something higher and do your forwarding/NAT this way.

jmckee : The server that I cant access is my own server on the network but the one I can access is a shared server that i dont own

jmeehan11 : I forwarded port to 32401 but I dont know how to do the rest on the router … wht am I looking for ???

Here’s the guide I use when setting up port forwards.

Set up a static IP for your Plex server.
Go into your router and create a manual port forward rule for port 47222 (just an example but don’t use 32400), for protocol TCP, that points to your Plex server’s IP and port 32400.
Save that and power cycle your router.
Go into the Plex server remote access settings, tick the box next to manual port, enter 47222, click apply, then disable remote access, shut down and restarted the Plex server application, and enable remote access.
Go to http://www.canyouseeme.org and test port 47222.
Go to http://www.whatsmyip.org and compare that IP address with what your router WAN IP is and what Plex reports as your public IP.

Repeat that for the second server, but use 47223 instead of 47222.