Handling of movies in multiple collections: Priority between show/hide items setting

This is about how Plex handles e.g. movies which are part of multiple collections with conflicting display settings.

My default setting is to hide items of a collection. This definitely works great for franchise collections (such as Iron Man, The Matrix, Star Wars…) – not so much for other clusters such as Oscar Winners or studio based collections such as Pixar/Studio Ghibli movies. For those I do like to see the individual movies on top of the collection.
One of the updates earlier this year added the functionality to override display/visibility settings for individual collections (great addition – thank you!).

Here comes the catch…
Things go wrong when you start having movies that are part of multiple collections.
With my library configured to hide items of a collection, having a separate collection which is configured to deviate from that setting results in all items to be displayed no matter what (+ their collections).

Example:

  • Collections (hide items)
    • Iron Man (containing Iron Man 1-3)
    • Captain America (containing Captain America 1-3)
    • Thor (containing Thor 1-3)
  • Cluster Collection (show collection and its items)
    • Marvel Cinematic Universe (containing Iron Man 1-3, Captain America 1-3, Thor 1-3, Doctor Strange and Spider Man Homecoming)

I would like to see that the hide items setting overrides the show items/show collection and its items settings. So as long as a movie is in a group that tells it to hide, this should be the rule.

Item Expected Result Current Result Comment
Iron Man, Captain America and Thor collections visible visible
Iron Man 1-3, Captain America 1-3 and Thor 1-3 movies hidden visible all those movies have a collection of their own which overrides the display items of the Marvel Cinematic Universe collection.
Marvel Cinematic Universe collection visible visible
Doctor Strange and Spider Man: Homecoming movies visible visible these 2 movies are not part of another collection.

A post was merged into an existing topic: Collection Display Issue