Now this may be a complete coincidence, and is probably not a long term solution but I thought I’d post it anyways.
I was able to get remote access working on my PLEX server that is also running behind PIA VPN.
Background: My ISP provides a router that is crap and can’t go in bridge mode, so I installed my own router, and designated it as the DMZ from the ISP router. Then I designated my plex streaming server box as the DMZ from my router.
- Open plex, and turn on remote access on the server (without a VPN, things should work fine)
(i don’t have a specific port specified, since it’s DMZ, it shouldn’t matter. I will click retry connection and wait until it shows the internet, connected to my public ip, then my private ip.) - Connect to the VPN AFTER remote access has been turned on.
For whatever reason, I think doing it in this order creates the server based on your PRE-VPN IP address (your real IP address), so when someone goes to stream off of it, they connect to your public IP rather than your VPN IP.
This seems to continue to work UNTIL your house gets a new public IP, usually only after power outages in my case.
I don’t claim that this will work for everyone, but it’s what I do for now until I get around to either doing a VM or a dedicated machine as the plex server