Same-name daily shows recordings fail to record

OK, so no season/episode info to differentiate.

Yes, agreed. This is worth reporting here to get Plex to recognise this as a date based show.

This is the Plex info on date-based naming:

Date-Based Television Shows

TV Shows that are date-based should be named as follows:

    • /TV Shows/ShowName/Season 02/ShowName – 2011-11-15 – Optional_Info.ext
    • /TV Shows/ShowName/Season 02/ShowName – 15-11-2011 – Optional_Info.ext

Where you specify the appropriate date. The date can use either the YYYY-MM-DD or DD-MM-YYYY formats and can use different separators:

  • Dashes (2011-11-15)
  • Periods (2011.11.15)
  • Spaces (2011 11 15)

[edit: Typo]