Thank you. I will send the logs in a moment. Out of the many times I’ve attempted this, I restarted the Mac server only once to see what would happen. Ideally I’d like to not restart it at all; I’d just like to get rid of it since the NAS is replacing it. The only reason I have not deleted the Mac server outright is because I want to get the NAS running first. Obviously have had no luck with that. I get to step 6, but I do not see anywhere in Plex Settings a place to claim the server. The Mac server is still stopped, I click the settings icon in the top right (next to the cast icon and the Head/Gravatar icon) and I’m taken to Plex Web - General and I see this in the left sidebar:

Seems like I’m missing that Plex Settings > Server > General option.