Parental Controls / Multiple User accounts

do the votes really matter??
Hey plex folks,

Once again I am amazed with the truly cool stuff you have released. The android client looks very sweet. But I have a question. Are the devs focusing on the most highly voted sugs/bugs or is this just a place for interested parties to brainstorm?

Is has been years since we lost the ability to have Multiple User accounts. I have been told repeatedly that it is "coming". But time and time again new features are added without any sign of parental controls. I don't know about you, but I am about to turn plex off since my kids are getting to the age of wanting to watch R rated films. I need a way to restrict this so I can keep using this fantastic software.

With about 200 votes for Parental Controls and over 300 for Multiple User account, I would say the people have spoken!

Sorry for the rant, but as a now paying customer I felt it was time to voice a stronger opinion on this matter.


[You have "spoken" wisely](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-_IlNbsILLE)

And fully agree here

/Tommy

for the time being you can do this to prevent your kids from accessing content on a per section basis.


  1. In the server myplex setting (show advanced settings) check require authentication on local network.


  2. Clients signed in with your myplex account can see everything



    3 Make a myplex account for your kids and only share the sections you want. Sign into clients with that myplex with that account for kids.



    I grant you this is not as “simple” user wise as some of the ways some have asked for it to be implemented (hiding r rated movies for example)

thanks for the tip, I will give it a try… I thought I had something similar working on my roku, but it only worked if I had two full fledged servers running. thanks for the tip.



What I would like, is the following:

When accessing locally, "Public Local" folders should be visible......And on the top right corner, a login box

When clicked, you should be able to logon to either a local PMS account, or an LDAP based account

After that, section refresh, and you could see the "nasty" stuff

What I don't want, is for my kids to logon.....it's too complicated for them, IMHO

/T

I completely agree with that it should be easier for kids and other family members to log in and out. Or the way you described. I was just letting him know of something he can do now to block his kids from stuff

lets not make this a thread about what we would like to see. This is a thread about the priorities of the dev team with respect to the voting on this forum. We have plenty of threads to discuss how parental controls/ multiples users can work.



I hope someone from the dev team will chime in here.

They wont. They have stated numerous times they do not comment on future features. If or when they will be implemented



Sadly to me, I agree, I tried to steel the Thread....Shame on me......and I will now return to my cave :lol:

+1 for parental controls of any kind

+1 Good idea :slight_smile:

+1

+1000

Before my kids get much older and I don’t need this anymore, been waiting since 2010

Or you could keep a closer eye on your kids.



Something tells me you're not a parent.


What a stupid thing to say!

I categorise our TV into two library's called "TV (Adults)" and "TV (Kids)" originally implemented to save us having to scroll through shows we are not interested in.

As my children have grown older, there are more shows that they are allowed to watch, that are not really Children's shows so they are allowed to watch some things that are in our library.
For example the "TV (Kids)" Library had stuff in like "iCarly" , "Hannah Montana" etc. which clearly fell into a Children's category. Now they are old enough to watch things like "The Simpsons" , "Friends" etc. which were filed in the Adult library. The odd episode in "Friends" is still perhaps a bit adult at times for them, but its mostly harmless.

As they get older, there will be more things they will be allowed to watch and bless them, they always ask permission when they have run out of stuff to watch but this is not the point!!!!!!

I have two well behaved girls who I trust implicitly, but I'm sure some households, perhaps with a rebellious teenager, might not be able to work on trust!

Quite frankly having to manually manage libraries, like I've already tried and working on trust is not something users should be expected to do for whats supposed to be a state of the art media system like Plex!

In fact when I wrote that last statement (and hopefully when people read it too) they will realise just how ridiculous it sounds. As Plex has grown significantly over the last few years, it seems ludicrous that such a basic / expected feature such as Parental Controls still does not exist!

Are we saying that Plex is only for the "non-family" oriented demographic or for people that simply don't care about protecting their children from in-approriate material???





100% agree.
If I was jdechambeau, revisiting this thread, I'd be embarrassed to have posted something so daft!

Fully agree... It has been on the roadmap for close to 3 years now. Sadly, there has been no indication whatsoever that we'll see it anytime soon :(


Well, it is really not our business whether the members of the dev team have children or not. But speaking in general terms, if developers don't have kids and if a project is being developed based on the interests of these developers (in casu Plex), the incentive to add family oriented features (such as Parental Controls or household PlexPass accounts) is likely modest...


What a stupid thing to say!


100% agree.
If I was jdechambeau, revisiting this thread, I'd be embarrassed to have posted something so daft!

Nah, no regrets. No kids but I don't think it's too much to expect that if you plop your kids in front of the tv or ipad you should have some idea what's on it. Ask me again in 5 years.

At any rate I was thinking more about this, an easy middle road solution would be to get daily reports of what's watched optionally emailed to you.

If your kids are curious enough to watch your adult stuff they'll be curious enough to figure out how to access your files on their own. Might as well know about it.

Nah, no regrets. No kids but I don't think it's too much to expect that if you plop your kids in front of the tv or ipad you should have some idea what's on it. Ask me again in 5 years.

At any rate I was thinking more about this, an easy middle road solution would be to get daily reports of what's watched optionally emailed to you.

If your kids are curious enough to watch your adult stuff they'll be curious enough to figure out how to access your files on their own. Might as well know about it.

Above all, I think that it is curious that non-parents want to have an opinion about the necessity for parental controls... :unsure: 

It is quite apparent that you have some biased ideas about parents and parenting (probably based on what you have "learned" from the media, i.e. that kids watch too much TV, maybe with an added twist of socioeconomic pseudoanalysis).

Let me give you some perspective and broaden your horizon...

My close family currently consists of myself, my wife and our two kids. We are highly educated academics (two PhDs).

My oldest son (2,5 years) is very capable with his iPad (often more so than his mom or his grandparents). He has learned the numbers and the alphabet and a lot of other advanced stuff independently by playing with it, e.g. when he didn't feel like playing with his parents (we do that a lot too) or with his Lego. The whole day long (apart from the weekends) he is in kindergarden (7-8 hours a day) where there is only "classic entertainment" and other kids available (no iPads or PCs or TVs). In between we also find the time to include him in cooking our meals, going to child gymnastics, reading old school books and other non-IT stuff...

So we don't "plop" our kids in front of the telly or an iPad - we deliberately allow it to give him a little break (1 hour max, and usually he wants to do other stuff after 30 min) from forced human interaction. With the iPad (or with carefully selected intelligent TV shows) it has the added benefit that kids actually learn something. And I am always within 10 meters of him in the same room when he uses it...

On his iPad my son has the Plex app - he knows it as his own backyard... By only allowing him to access the sections of our library that I share with him via myPlex, we actually have some degree of parental controls, but as of now it is more like a hack than an actual feature.

Certainly it requires me to maintain and cultivate library sections based on an archaic file system folder hierarchy. Plex is all about metadata, and by logical extension parental controls also should be based on the rich metadata already available.

Finally, sending me an email that my son has bypassed my rudimentary myPlex based controls (it really only requires him to flip one switch in the iOS app - the "Find Nearby Servers" switch) and watched the scary scenes in The Exorcist won't reverse the unfortunate effects...

Finally, sending me an email that my son has bypassed my rudimentary myPlex based controls (it really only requires him to flip one switch in the iOS app - the "Find Nearby Servers" switch) and watched the scary scenes in The Exorcist won't reverse the unfortunate effects...

Hey MTII I am not here to argue the finer points of parenting or the value of this feature (i do think it would be valuable). but your son should not be able to just hit "find nearby servers" and get in if you have "require authentication on local networks" checked in the server myPlex settings (show advances options). if he can then there is a serious bug with that and you should make another thread so the devs are aware