So apparently I had two accounts. One with my gmail address and one with a different email.
I was trying to “clear up” this mess, but logging into my gmail account (which is the one I’m posting from) and pressing delete account from within the account settings. Everything seemed to be successful, but now when I try to login with my OTHER account (username: Dynde87) it says password invalid, and when I do the “forgot password” it says it sent the password (if an account exists) but I receive no emails. I also can’t “sign up” with this email to register again as it says “Email has already been taken”.
In addition, my plex server says it’s signed in with the Dynde87 account’s email under settings.
And apparently plex has no direct customer support for something like this!?