Ah. Thanks for the additional information and clarifying it’s just a problem migrating from Mac to Mac.
We can either try to get the Mac install claimed and visible or reinstall the Mac PMS and restore your metadata.
Because we’re having difficulty reaching the new Mac’s PMS, I should ask why did you leave the Synology server in Authorized Devices? Is that a working server?
I’m in favor of doing a Mac PMS complete uninstall then install from scratch, getting a test PMS running on the Mac, then restoring data to get around this issue of being directed to the Syno Server.
You can ignore the advice about migrating PMS from Syno to Mac as that’s not your situation. You won’t need the FordGuy topic I linked previously.
Copy your ~/Library/Application Support/Plex Media Server to another folder on the Mac, out of your ~/Library, to protect it from deletion while retaining user, group, and permissions.
To do the following steps, the things that cause the least headaches are whether you had these two boxes unchecked on your original Mac PMS in Settings → Library

If that’s how you had those settings, then follow the next steps.
However, if you had those checked, don’t follow the steps yet and tell me.
If you don’t remember, don’t follow the steps and tell me.
Steps to uninstall, reinstall a test PMS
- Use the
delpms.sh script to completely uninstall PMS because you still have the contents of ~/Library somewhere that you can restore again later.
- You next download and install PMS on the Mac, going through setup to get it running with the same server name and create a test library with one video, and prove you can access it and play the video. The infinite spinning topic I linked above will walk you through that.
Let us know if you get this far successfully.
Steps to Restore your old media and metadata
- Quit out of PMS on the Mac.
- Then put all your movie, tv shows, music, and photo files back in the same location where the old PMS knew them to be located.
- You should manually copy your original
~/Library/Application Support/Plex Media Server folder into your new Mac’s same ~/Library location and Replace the existing one that was created during the test PMS install.
- Then restart the Mac and start PMS to have it run using the restored metadata and media. It should return a
claimed=1 when you do the identity URL, because you created and claimed a test server then restored metadata to it.
Tell us how it worked.
On Linux, PMS stores its unique configuration in Preferences.xml but on a Mac that config is stored in ~/Library/Preferences/com.plexapp.plexmediaserver.plist
Because you got PMS running and playing a video in a test install, you made a working plist. Because you did not overwrite that plist but only restored the metadata folder, the working plist should run your restored metadata seamlessly.
You can view your PMS plist using
defaults read com.plexapp.plexmediaserver
and that should output your MachineID, token, username, email, everything that should make it claimed and accessible.
Does that make sense?
