The recent change we made was to display the track year if there was one, in advance of supporting that more detailed metadata. See what the track itself looks like.
But very strange, because the “originallyAvailableAt” show the date that i added the album to the library, so it seems a problem with plex or something.
Did more tests, and looks like the problem its with the “Scanner” and “Agent” options, when on both are on Plex Music it shows the correct year, but when is “Plex Music Scanner” and “Personal Media Artists” respectively, then it shows the wrong year (2023). I did this with 'prefer local metadata" option checked in both cases.
I’m going to give the Plex Music agent another shot today, as I’m also seeing this same issue in Plexamp. I’ve purposely avoided using Plex Music agent as last time I tried it (maybe 2 years ago) it had a tendency to completely mangle my collection, e.g. splitting albums into 2 and refusing to acknowledge the “Prefer Local Metadata” option in many cases. It wasn’t due to issues with my metadata - if I deleted the library and tried it again with the exact same settings, it would split different albums.
At the time, the older Plex Music Scanner with Personal Media Artists was the only way I could get Plex to read my tags 100% and not randomly split albums. I have no intention of letting Picard loose on my extensively curated large collection of music, as previous attempts using a small test subset of my music have proved fruitless.
But enough moaning - I’ve just set up a test library using Plex Music Agent and will report back tomorrow once it’s finished scanning. Hopefully things will be more satisfactory now.
Quick Update: I’ve just scanned in my smaller CD singles folder using the Plex Music agent, and things seem to be so much better than when I last tried it. Plex seems to be adhering to my “Prefer Local Metadata” option this time. I’ll give it a go on my main Albums folder now
I’m still struggling to see how the Plex Music agent is “far superior in many ways”. I created a test library yesterday using the Plex Music agent, and with “Prefer Local Metadata” set. It’s just finished scanning now, and here’s the results:
Logitech Media Server shows 11944 albums with 136273 tracks.
Bluesound shows 11944 albums with 136273 tracks.
Foobar2000 shows 11944 albums with 136273 tracks.
Plex using the old Plex Music Scanner and Personal Media Artists shows 11944 albums with 136273 tracks.
However, Plex using the “superior” Plex Music agent and Prefer Local Metadata shows 11587 albums with 135300 tracks.
So the Plex Music agent is missing 357 albums and 973 tracks. From an initial look at a couple of artists where I have lots of albums (and comparing with LMS, Bluesound and Foobar2000), I can see that Plex is merging albums together based on folder structures rather than Album Name tags, and that it isn’t always using the embedded artwork, despite the library being set to Album Art Local Files Only. This is why some of us still rely on the older Plex Music Scanner with Personal Media Artists… it behaves much better for people who want full control over their tags and library. Plex Music agent is the only software I’ve ever used that tries doing its own thing (actually that’s not quite true: Roon also mangles things by trying to be clever)
It’s not only Plex and Roon, for example Emby also tries to be too clever by splitting /disc1/ and /disc2/ subfolders into separate albums. But yes, the less “intelligence” the less the scanner appears to the user as a black box. This is always my pet peeve around Plex not supporting the Compilation tag: sure you can have a clever algorithm around track artist, album artist, album title, folder structure and file name tags to determine whether an album is a compilation, but it does make things a lot easier (and mif the scanner just reads Compilation = true.
This work towards Plex handling individual track years (and hopefully, track genres) is very positive news btw!
Here’s an example. There’s a Depeche Mode boxset with 4 discs dedicated to different eras, each with their own album title and artwork. Here’s how it’s displayed in Logitech Media Server:
Plex Music Scanner with Personal Media Artists also displays it this way:
However, here’s what Plex Music agent shows. It’s merged all 4 CDs into a single entry (resulting in the title showing as the first of the 4 discs):
Drilling down into the single album does show the 4 discs individually, but you lose the disc-specific title and artwork. Despite me telling Plex to Prefer Local Metadata, it seems to be using the folder structure to group the 4 discs into a single entry rather than keep them as 4 separate entries.
I realise this might be getting slightly off-topic, but at the end of the day Plexamp has recently started showing the wrong year in the Now Playing screen if using the older Plex Music Scanner with Personal Media Artists. Rather than resolve the issue, it’s been recommended that we switch to the newer scanner, so I’m just trying to show that there’s valid reasons why some of us stick with the older scanner.
Thanks for the extra information. We generally consider merging multi-disc albums to be a feature I understand there are those rare cases where there is per-album metadata.