PMS Already Installed, but asking to install it?

The fact that you see this page means that Plex server is indeed running.
It’s just that you are unable to access it, due to a problem with the user authentication.
The cure for that is forcing the server out of its currently used Plex user account and re-claiming fresh – just like you did when you installed it the first time.

Here is a tool which aims to streamline the procedure described in this support article: