Trouble setting up Remote access

Server Version#: 1.43.5.11079
Player Version#: Plex for Android 4.50.19

I can’t get past the remote access page telling me the server is “Not available outside your network” I’ve been trying different things for about 2 weeks with no luck.

My setup:
I’m running a the media server on a raspberry pi (Trixie) connected to an external hard drive that is hosting my media. I’m connected through an Asus RP-AX58 AiMesh wifi extender, which is connected to a Asus RT-AX82U router then a Motorola modem (MB7621). According to natchecker.com I’m behind a PRC-NAT, but according to everything I’ve read the Modem only works in bridge mode, so there is no NAT there, and from what I understand from my traceroute logs, I’m not behind a CG-NAT, because none of the hops are in the 100.xxx.xxx.x range.

results of my traceroute:

The extenders also don’t handle DHCP, so there’s no NAT there either, there is only 1 network and both the router and the extenders are on it. I’m not connected through a VPN. I have a Lifetime Plex Pass if that makes a difference. I have physical and LAN access to all devices and I can stream my library locally through Plexamp. Also, my raspberry pi has a static IP address, as I know that can sometimes be an issue.

What I’ve tried, each done separately:

-I’ve tried setting up port forwarding with 32400 and ports I saw on the remote access page when I’m not defining my own port.

-I’ve enabled UPnP with no change

-I’ve enabled Port Trigger with no change

-I’ve enabled Open NAT with no change

What I haven’t tried:

Connecting directly to the modem (wired or wirelessly), as I have access to it, but I can’t permanently connect the raspberry pi to it.

I’ve included my logs, so hopefully someone that understands networks better can make sense of my issue.

Plex Media Server Logs_2026-11-19_11-57-22.zip (2.2 MB)

When you set a port in plex under manually specify and create the forwarding rule on your router for that port, does it show open via https://canyouseeme.org/ ?

If so, can you hit the server directly via http://<public-ip>:32400/web (change 32400 to whatever port you set in plex)?

I’m seeing the TLS error in your logs which could mean you need to refresh your certificate. After doing the steps above, if it shows success and you can hit it directly, follow these steps:

Stop plex, go to the Cache directory in the Plex Media Server folder, is there a certificate.p12 file? If so, rename it certificate.p12.old and start plex. It should download cert-v2.p12. See it the status goes green and you have remote access from clients.

Worked perfectly! Thank you. Looks like it was just the cert out of date.