Video stutters

So I can’t pinpoint when or what made this happen. But every time I start a video it stutters. I can fix it by doing the following. I have to change the playback quality to “play original” then back to “convert automatically” and the video stops stuttering. Is there anyway to fix this? I have briefly played around with changing Internet streaming quality and home streaming quality to lower modes and to maximum but can’t seem to get it fixed without having to switch the quality back-and-forth.