You have the Plex Movies & Shows enabled on your account and pinned to your sidebar.
Either when you searched for a show/movie that you know you have on your server, it is also on Plex Movies & Shows and you clicked on that and started watching it from there. The other way it could happen is that selecting a show/movie from continue watching can start it from Plex Movies & Shows if it exist there.
So you have 2 options.
- Disable Plex Movies & Shows from your account settings under the Online Media Sources section
- Unpin Plex Movies & Shows from your side bar and then the continue watching aspect won’t happen. (You might need to change a setting to prevent Plex from searching Plex Movies & Shows if you only do the unpinning, but I am not sure about that. Hopefully someone more knowledgeable can verify as I have Movies & Shows disabled).
-Shark2k
