Having the same show in two different libraries impact each other's watch status

I have a standard TV library with regular HD content and a 4K TV Library and for example the show the expanse in both libraries. When the new season came in both the 720p and 4k show up on my Continue watching section.

If I remove one (doesn’t matter which version) both are removed. If I mark the 720p one as watched it marks my 4K one as watched too

Very annoying. Anyone know of a fix?

I’m using the latest beta via docker on unraid.

It happening on my Apple TV and Samsung TV app so I don’t believe it’s client related.

That’s how it works, they’re both the same movie so we track them the same.

There is an open feature request to support alternate editions of movies, while this is not exactly what it’s purpose is, it would serve as a work-around if that gets implemented.

You can vote here: Multiple Cuts Of Movie - #714 by GigiFacon

The difference is it’s a TV show not a movie and it’s a seperate library. I don’t see how marking some watched in one library should affect an item (same or not) in another library.

1 Like

Doesn’t matter if it’s a series or a movie, if they’re the same item they should be tracked the same. If you have the same item duplicated in multiple libraries and watch one of the copies, you’ve still watched that content.

The feature request I linked would be applicable for TV shows too.

The link you provided is asking for a a way to choose version that is assuming that the media is stored in the same folder for example

/media/tv/show/season 1/ ep1hd.mkv
/media/tv/show/season 1/ ep1SDmkv

Mine are

/Media/tv/show name

/Media/4kTV/show name

So in my case it’s not only a different library it’s a different location of the media as well.

I am not sure but, maybe, if you use a different agent for each library you might disconnect the watched status. I have run into the same thing but, at least so far, it has not bothered me enough to try to find an answer.

Location doesn’t matter. The unique GUIDs given to items is what we use to track this, so if both libraries use the same agent then they’ll track together.

Yeah I find it a real pain in the butt when you go to continue washing and you see both the 4K and the regular HD one in the list and when you mark one or remove one from watch to remove both even though they are in completely different locations on my server and in separate libraries

A good tip if you don’t want this to happen is to exclude your 4K library from the home screen.

Edit Library → Advanced → Visibility → Exclude From Home Screen

That’s an idea. I used to use two Dockers of Plex on two different servers however I’m down to one now

Cheers

Get rid of the lower resolution version. You can always down-convert 4k to 720p or even 480i. No reason to keep two of the same thing.

Nope I don’t share my 4K Library but I do share my regular TV Library

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.