Your comment makes a ton of assumptions about user needs, and feels pretty dismissive.
First, no. The crux of the issue is that if I have more than one version of a movie, there is now no way to see them in any meaningful way other than scrolling to where they are in my full library. If I want to, for example, watch the GOUT edit of Empire Strikes Back, please tell me how I’m supposed to do that from the attached screenshots (which is what I get on the new search results page). This results page is literally worthless. You yourself had a clear reaction the first time you saw that “versions” modal. And yet literally nothing has been done about it.
Secondly, as @VBB pointed out, for users that split their standard and 4K movies into different libraries (to avoid remote users streaming 4K, for example), the search results page still combines them with a “+1” and the exact same worthless modal that provides literally zero identifying information. Please, explain to me how this is in any way usable, or how edition support would solve this when the results page is literally collapsing multiple libraries into singular “results”.
Finally, it honestly sounds to me like the upcoming Edition support isn’t really going to align with how I (and many other users) prefer to manage and display our libraries. I don’t want all of the versions of a movie to show up under a singular movie entry. That would nuke so many of the features I currently use.
- I prefer having each version as its own entry in my library, in order to take advantage of the unique key art for each version. Most fan edits have awesome custom posters, and I want to see them in my library.
- I keep fan edits in a “Fan Edits” collection. I also have a “Star Wars Fan Edits” collection for Star Wars specific edits, and I have an “Album Syncs” collection for things like Dark Side of the Rainbow. If the multiple versions aren’t their own entries in my library, these collections disappear.
- Similarly, I have a Marvel Cinematic Universe collection and an MCU 4K collection. Same for Disney Animated Features and Pixar features, as some examples. I use really cool special key art for my 4K versions, and it’s one of my favorite things about my digital collection. Again, it sounds like edition support will nuke this.
- A number of “versions” I have are so different I would never want them rolled into a parent entry for any reason. Album syncs are their own creations. And edits like The War of the Stars are also completely their own beasts and nothing like the original source material. Having them show up under the original film’s entry makes zero sense.
The point of all the above is that no, Edition support will not remove the need to split these titles apart. Nor will it fix the issues caused by the completely useless new search results page.
I just don’t understand why the search results page was changed? Just leave it the way it was. It worked perfectly.
And in case you’re curious as to what kind of “Edition support” would actually be beneficial, simply having the option to turn off the merging of all versions whenever a new version is added would solve so many of my problems (the new search results page not being one of them, though). Additionally, being able to manually populate more detailed metadata like cast and production/distribution companies would be amazing. I could be in a minority when it comes to this opinion, but personally I don’t want more things streamlined and made “simple”. I want more granular control over my collection. But that’s a different conversation. The way it corresponds to the current topic is that, as a user with a significant number of fan edits and 1080+4K movies in my collection, the new search results page is horrible and the upcoming Editions support will not solve my need to see each version of a movie on the results page itself. No one asked for this collapsed results view. I don’t see how anyone at Plex can look at it and actually think it’s helpful. It needs to be reverted to the previous results page behavior in order for it to have any usability.