[repost] FireTV External ASS subtitles are ignored in playback

So my old report closed. But let’s not mistake that for meaning the issue went away, I just forgot to babysit the thread and bump it again.

Currently at:
Server Version#: 1.19.4.2935
Player Version#: 8.2.1.18636 (Amazon Fire Stick 4K, using New Player)

Hi, this has been an issue for awhile, and I know this has been reported before, but nothing ever came of it. The Fire TV client doesn’t seem to handle external ASS subtitle tracks. Plex Server sees them and lists them, and I can select them for playback, but they aren’t actually being played.

They should be triggering the playback to transcode back on the server in my case, and that’s not happening, and the Fire TV client is not trying to direct play them either, as I’d at least still see text if that was the case. All I get is the video direct playing (which isn’t playing right, but that’s a whole other topic), the audio, and no subs at all. If the subs are muxxed into the file they play back (as transcoded) normally.

I exported the ASS subs to SRT for an episode and added it to the server. I can select the external SRT version of the track and the subs display. Just not the original ASS subs, if they are external.

1 Like

Server Version#: 1.20.1.3252
Player Version#: 8.6.0.20351 (Amazon Fire Stick 4K, using New Player)

No change. External ASS subs are still presented as an option and select-able, but the client/server are not actually playing them when using the “Automatic” setting for subtitle transcoding. If the same subs are muxed into the file, they play/transcode correctly.

Server Version#: 1.21.0.3616
Player Version#: 8.10.0.21911 (Amazon Fire Stick 4K, using New Player)

No change from before. Fire Stick lists the external ASS subs but they are not played when selected.

Server Version#: 1.21.3.4015
Player Version#: 8.11.0.22186

No change. External ASS subtitles only get played when I have the subtitle transcode setting on “always”. When using the “automatic” setting the subs are not played at all.

Still no response, and coming up on one year for this thread.

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.