Starting Over

Cool.

Do you still have all your data in the “Plex” share? (Plex/Library/Application Support/Plex Media Server) ?

If you do, we can move it over.

If this is strictly a permissions problem (not seeing the media) the answer is SIMPLE.
Grant permission for System Internal User ‘PlexMediaServer’ instead of “Plex”/

DSM 7 forced the change.

Everything is documented here.

If you still want to wipe it all out, it’s very easy .

I’ll give you the instructions.