Clicking Play *STILL* fails on an AppleTV using a HomePod for audio

Continuing the discussion from AutoPlay fails when AppleTV uses HomePods back in April 2024:

I have an AppleTV and an AppleTV 4K (with a homepod). Clicking “play” on the “old” AppleTV immediately starts playing, but not for the AppleTV4K – For the ATV4K, I have to click “play” 3 or 4 times to get anything to play. The first click brings up the first frame of the video, but it doesn’t play until the 3rd or 4th click.

Well, the work-around noted above for the OLD problem still works-around this issue.

Come on folks, it’s been over six months, and several iOS versions of Plex – when will this be fixed?

Now… Player Version#: 8.42 (9478)

2 Likes

The OLD Audio Player really sucks… When watching a show, pressing “pause” now takes a second or three before the audio pauses (the video pauses immediately).

Sigh…

I’m also having this problem. For certain videos, playback is entirely unwatchable. The audio continues fine, but the video drops to a whopping 5 seconds per frame. Read that again, not 5 frames per second, 5 seconds per frame!

tvOS version 8.43 (9537) just appeared and…

I turned off the “old audio player” and ---- Voila, The “clicking play fails” went away!
Clicking play on an Apple TV 4K using a HomePod for audio now works!!! Woo Hoo!

uh, oh… I spoke too early…

The problem has only gone away SOMETIMES.

When I first used the Apple TV 4K Plex after not using it for a while, the problem IS STILL THERE – it takes three clicks of play button to work.

BUT, when I’m watching something and press pause then back to Plex App home, pressing play on a title (cover image) once works!

BUT, when I went to another APP for a while, and back to the Plex App, it also then takes three clicks of play to begin actually playing.

I came here for this. I had my AppleTV 4k 2nd Gen on my Samsung with a soundbar and all was fine. The soundbar crapped out so I got a HomePod to replace it and started seeing all the issues listed above. It’s like the videos start paused - then you have to click play/pause again a couple of times to start playback. Sometimes, it will play a few minutes and then the Plex app crashes (and a couple of times it has rebooted the AppleTV as well).
Playing the same shows on my 1st Gen AppleTV 4k have no issues.

Last night, I had another issue crop up where the audio cut out after 3-5 minutes of playback. The only way to get it back was to stop playback and start it again.

I’ll try the ‘old audio’ work-around when I get home tonight.

Are there any log files generated somewhere on the client? I searched the server logs and didn’t find anything abnormal.

1 Like

I recently upgraded to latest Apple TV box and am having the same issues - using dual homepods for audio, many shows won’t start when clicking them - have to hit play a bunch of times. And full auto cutout happens almost everything I watch at some point - have to exit and go back in.

I tried the “old audio” trick and got no audio at all.

Is there anything we can do?

as of the latest version (installed today, released dec 11, 2024, version 8.4.4), playing on a HomePod fails completely. if you can get it to start playing after 10-20 clicks, it loses audio within about 1 minute of play, forcing a restart of plex to get it to start again.

also, switching to “old audio player” causes no audio at all.

in previous versions, it would at least eventually start working, after many attempts to play, but this new version is extremely bad in that it simply will not play more than a minute, if you can get it to play at all.

what happened? will there be an update to address this, or the ongoing audio problems?

editing to add, before it loses all audio, first one of the dual HomePods stops working, then the audio drops to about 50%, then the audio disappears completely.

@deprived and @ohmyjosh, I tried the old audio trick last night and also got no audio at all. I switched it back and got audio (but had the click issue). I then went back and switched to old audio and restarted the AppleTV and it works fine now (aside from the listed issues with old audio like sound playing longer than the video when pausing / skipping intro).

Hello Plex staff…

We really do need to finally get this bug fixed. Please at least post some status report on when you’ll fix this.

Same problem here. I have two apple tv 4ks.

  • One has two homepod mini’s in a stereo pair, the other uses audio through the TV (hdmi).
  • The problem reliably happens only on the TV with the homepod mini pair.
  • Other apps (netflix, prime) do not not have this problem.

Been paying for the Infuse player for over a year now because Plex doesnt care to support one of the most common scenarios for using their product.

One thing is sure, Plex will never get one cent of my money again. It’s funny, when I started using infuse I thought the UI was worse than Plex’s but today Plex has enshittified itself so much that it would be a downgrade to go back to their player.

1 Like

Hey Plex Admins,

This bug has been ongoing for a YEAR now. How about fixing it, please!

1 Like

I tried the suggested workaround today, and this is still a problem.

I love using the HomePods for audio, but videos start paused on the new audio engine, and on the old one, they start silent for several seconds.

Apple TV 4K (A2737)
tvOS v18.4.1 [22L261]
Plex v8.45 (9684)

If there is any other information I can provide to help resolve this, please let me know.

1 Like

It’s crazy how long they’ve plugged their ears and ignored this problem.

2 Likes

This bug is well known by Plex.tv for over a year now…!

I wish that the-powers-that-be would at least tell us what we need to do to get them to fix it!!!

1 Like

Please, please fix this Plex!

This topic was automatically closed 90 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.